Secateurs why choose an anvil, bypass/parrot-beak or double blade type?

There are varying qualities of secateurs from budget to professional quality.  But why are there different types of blades fitted to secateurs?  Usually, the range extends from bypass (or parrot-beak type), anvil and double blade.

gt118web-300x107

Bypass or Parrot-beak secateurs:  as the name suggests the blade bypasses the counter blade to make a cut.  (i.e. the action is similar to scissors).  One blade is convex and the other concave.  The main reason you would use the bypass to cut smaller branches and dense foliage as the blades are thinner and allow easier manoeuvrability e.g. with vines or roses.

gt170lowe1-300x207

Anvil secateurs:  Have an upper blade which pushes down to an anvil counter blade (i.e. they close to a flat surface).  The blade is bigger than the Bypass and the action tends to slice rather than squash the branch.   Anvil secateurs will give a clean cut.  Anvil is used for softer wooded trees and plants like Cherries, Pear and Olives.

 

lisamsecs_web-300x187

Double-Blade secateurs:  Have two identical blades if you compare to the anvil or bypass type.  These secateurs make a cut by slicing the branch from two sides of the stem.  Since you are cutting equally from both sides you tend to finish the cut in the middle of the stem where a lip is present.  The reason for the lip at the end of the stem is to create angles each side and ensure that no water can settle on the cut to helping the wound heal without the added risk of infection.

When you use secateurs on a regular basis you need to take into account the clunk/jarring factor to reduce the impact for RSI (Repetitive Strain Injury) purposes of each of these models:

The clunk or jar factor is what you feel at the end of a cut.  A bypass secateurs gives the biggest clunk and you find these types of secateurs are not the choice of Arborists.  Whereas a Double blade type secateurs have some jarring and the Anvil has no jarring at all and is usually the choice for Arborists.

What else to look for when choosing the right secateurs?

Everyone has a different sized-hands and secateurs are made in a facade of different sizes and shapes.  Feel the secateurs in your hands open and close them like you are making a cut and feel if your hand can extend the reach of the handles when open.  Rolling handles may be an option or not.  The rolling handle model are usually more expensive and may not be better for the fit of your hand.

Here are some other facts about secateurs:

  • The maximum cutting capacity of secateurs is usually around 20mm up to 25mm depending on the robustness of the secateurs.
  • Keep them sharp, no secateurs will give a good or easy cut if blunt.
  • Choose forged steel blades as they are easier to sharpen than stainless steel blades.
  • Professional grade secateurs are slightly more cost upfront but give you the flexibility of replacing almost any part of the secateurs.  The blades like Lowe from Germany are hardened twice and heat treated.  So you get more mileage out of them.   Also, professional grade secateurs are made with alloys and tend to be lighter and easier to use for extended periods of time.
  • Budget secateurs are made to be disposable, they are usually much harder to cut within any model and tend to jar the worst.
  • Secateurs should have a grip handle so if you are pruning and your hands are wet then you still need to have a good grip on them.
  • Keep your secateurs clean and oiled.  One sure way of spreading disease in any grove or orchard is to prune a diseased tree then move onto healthy trees.  Dip your secateurs in a 25% diluted methylated spirits solution.  Oiling the blades after you have finished for the day will keep the secateurs in the best condition for longer.
  • The importance of a good clean cut can never be overstressed!

The next time you look for secateurs, take into consideration the application and frequency of use.  Choose what is comfortable and practical for your application!

Find more about Bypass, Anvil and Double Blade Secateurs

Other links:

Find more about Loppers

Find more Pruning Articles

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s